How do you make the first move as a lesbian? Say one clear, kind sentence out loud, like “I’d love to take you on a date”, then let her answer. If you’ve been flirting for months, there’s a good chance she’s waiting for you to go first. Here’s why you’re both stuck, and how to get unstuck.
Why does lesbian mutual pining happen?
First, babe, you’re in excellent company. Lesbian mutual pining is practically a rite of passage, and there’s research on why two people who clearly fancy each other can sit on it for months.
In 1996, researchers Jacquie Vorauer and Rebecca Ratner published six studies involving 544 people in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, all about who makes the first move. The trap they describe goes like this: you put your own silence down to fear of rejection, but you read her silence as a lack of interest. She’s doing exactly the same sum about you. Two people, both keen, both concluding “if she liked me, she’d have said something by now”.
Then there’s the script problem. Riki Thompson, a University of Washington Tacoma researcher who interviewed more than 100 people about online dating, wrote in The Conversation in 2022 that straight dating convention has long handed the opening move to men, from the flirting to the asking out. Most of us grew up watching that script on repeat. When it’s two women, or two people who were never cast as the one who asks, nobody’s been given the line.
And for queer women there’s often an extra layer. Amelia Sloan, a psychotherapist who specialises in queer sexuality, told Xtra Magazine in 2022 that a lot of their sapphic clients struggle with how to connect romantically with other women and femmes. One of the biggest reasons, Sloan says, is a feeling of somehow not being queer enough to act on it.
So no, you’re not being pathetic. You’re two people stuck in the same loop, each waiting for the other to break it.
How do you know it’s mutual and not just friendly?
Honestly? You can’t be 100% sure without asking, and waiting for certainty is how months go by. What you can do is look at the evidence.
Saving you a seat, texting most nights and finding reasons to stay a bit longer are not things people do for someone they feel neutral about. If you want a second opinion, run her through our guide to telling flirting from just being nice, and if you’re not even sure what your hangouts are, is it a date or just friends? will help.
Article continues below.
If she’s ticking most of the list, you don’t need more signs. You need a sentence.
One thing to skip: testing her. No mentioning other dates to see if she flinches, no going quiet to see if she chases. Tests tell you nothing useful and they make the other person feel wobbly. Asking is kinder, and quicker.
Your next read: Is it a date or just friends? The lesbian dating dilemma, solved
How do you make the first move as a lesbian, step by step?
Start with a re-frame. Making the first move isn’t being pushy, aggressive or predatory. It’s being open. You’re giving her a piece of information and a choice, and that’s a generous thing to do.
It also doesn’t need to be a grand gesture. Sloan’s advice is to begin with steps that feel safe and manageable to you, then build from there. So:
- Pick a moment, not the perfect moment. Somewhere you can hear each other and either of you can leave easily. The walk to the station beats shouting it over a speaker. Sober enough to mean it, too.
- Turn the flirting up one notch. Hold eye contact a beat longer. Swap “love the jacket” for “you look really good tonight”. You’re making it harder to file under friendly.
- Say the clear thing. One sentence with the word “date” in it, or the feeling itself. There are scripts below.
- Stop talking. The silence will feel like a year. Count to five and let her have it.
- Take her answer as the answer. A yes means book something this week, before you both lose your nerve. A “can I think about it?” means give her room. A no means no, and we’ll get to that.
What do you say to ask a girl out as a lesbian?
You don’t need a speech. You need one line you can get out before your brain talks you out of it. Pick whichever sounds most like you.
- The date ask: “I’d love to take you on an actual date. Are you free on Saturday?” The word “date” is doing the heavy lifting here. “We should hang out sometime” is how you got into this mess.
- The check-in: “I keep wondering if we’re flirting. I’m hoping we are.” Low pressure, very charming, and it hands her an easy way to say “obviously”.
- The lean-in and ask: when you’re close and the moment’s there, lean in a little and say, “Can I kiss you?” Asking doesn’t kill the mood. It’s hot, and it means you both know where you stand.
- The text, if your voice won’t cooperate: “I really like hanging out with you. I’d like to take you out, just us, as a date. No pressure either way.”
If you’d rather open with a joke, we once collected more than 70 lesbian pickup lines. Use with caution. And if you need somewhere to say it in person, The Bar Edit has queer bars where nobody will bat an eyelid.
What if she says no?
Then you’ll know, which beats another few months of wondering. It will sting, and that’s allowed.
This isn’t about growing a thick skin, either. Sloan is clear that they never advise people to simply take rejection over and over. The point is one honest risk, taken in a way that feels safe to you, with someone who has already shown she likes having you around.
If it’s a no, keep it short and gracious:
“Thanks for being honest. I’m glad I asked, and I’d still love to be mates.”
Then mean it. Turn up to the next thing as normal. Don’t sulk, don’t ask again in a fortnight and don’t make her manage your feelings. Take those to a friend instead, and give yourself a week or two to feel a bit bruised. Respecting her answer is what keeps the friendship possible, and most friendships can survive one brave, kind sentence.
But look at the evidence again. Months of flirting says the odds are on your side. As Sloan puts it: “Waiting for the hero never works.”
Go on. Say the sentence. Then tell us everything.
Nonchalant x
You may also like
Babs heads up Logistics and Product here at Nonchalant Magazine.
