It’s official: Newcastle United midfielder Jordan Nobbs and West End performer Erin Caldwell are getting married.
The couple announced their engagement in a joint Instagram post on Tuesday evening, sharing a beachside picture of their hands intertwined – Erin’s left hand stacked with a stunning oval-cut diamond. A second slide showed the pair wrapped up together in the candlelit dark, cheek-to-cheek, beaming.
Erin’s caption said it all: “It’s always been you.”
Within minutes, the comments section had become a roll-call of women’s football royalty. Beth Mead: “Omg !!! Congratulations my girls, over the moon for yous!” Katie McCabe, never knowingly understated: “Soooo happy for the chickens.” Caitlin Foord chimed in too. Jordan’s Arsenal Women alumni network showed up in force, as did Erin’s musical theatre world.
For anyone who’s been following along, the engagement feels like the inevitable next step in one of women’s football’s most quietly beloved love stories. Jordan and Erin went public in summer 2024, becoming an instant fan favourite across both the WoSo and West End fandoms – a footballer-meets-theatre-hero pairing that has spent the past two years gently dominating TikTok edits and Instagram reels. Erin, who played Jane Seymour in Six the Musical (touring and West End), has spoken openly about her relationship and LGBTQ+ representation, once telling a TikTok audience she “can’t really take the smile off my face” when she thinks about Jordan.
Jordan, meanwhile, has had a season of new beginnings of her own. After 13 years at Arsenal and two and a half at Aston Villa, the 33-year-old midfielder – and all-time WSL appearance record-holder – made the move north last summer to join Newcastle United Women in WSL2, returning to the part of the country she grew up in. She was named WSL2 Player of the Month and PFA Fans’ Player of the Month for December. Coming home in more ways than one, then.
This kind of public, joyful engagement announcement between two women in the spotlight still matters, and we love to see it. Persistent work of normalising queer love at scale. The 26K likes within two hours tell their own story.
There’s no word yet on a wedding date (obvs, give them a chance), a venue, or who’s giving a speech (WSL players – we see you). For now, we’re just here to say congratulations to them both.
Article continues below.
Much love,
Nonchalant x
You may also like
This article was written by one of our creative team writers here at Nonchalant Magazine.
