If you’ve ever Googled anything about lesbian relationships, you’ve probably seen the stat. Lesbian couples divorce more than anyone else. More than gay men. More than straight couples. The internet loves this fact. It gets cited in Reddit threads, on divorce lawyer blogs, and by the kind of people who think the existence of lesbian divorce proves something about the viability of queer relationships in general.
The stat isn’t entirely wrong. But the way it gets used is almost always misleading. And the actual story behind the numbers is much more interesting – and much more hopeful – than the headline suggests.
Skip to:
- What the data actually says
- Why these numbers are misleading
- What’s really going on?
- The bit nobody talks about
What the data actually says
Let’s start with the numbers, because they do exist and we’re not going to pretend they don’t.
In England and Wales, ONS data from 2019 showed that 72% of same-sex divorces were between female couples. That pattern has been consistent year on year – it was 78% in 2016, 74% in 2017, and 75% in 2018. By 2022, female couples still accounted for 69% of same-sex divorces.
In Norway, a 2022 study published in the Journal of Family History tracking same-sex marriages over 25 years found that divorce risks are highest in female same-sex marriages, whereas male same-sex marriages have the same divorce risk levels as different-sex marriages.
In the US, an NIH study looking at adoptive parents found a 12% break-up rate for lesbian couples, compared to 2% for gay male couples and 8% for heterosexual couples.
You may also like: What is Lesbian Bed Death, and how to prevent it
Article continues below.
So yes. By most available measures, lesbian couples do divorce at higher rates than both gay male couples and heterosexual couples. That part is real.
But here’s where it gets interesting.
Why these numbers are misleading
The data pool is tiny
Same-sex marriage has only been legal in England and Wales since 2014. That means the longest any same-sex marriage in the UK can have lasted at the time of most of these studies is about five to eight years. We’re looking at the very earliest cohort of legal marriages, many of which were between couples who had been waiting years – sometimes decades – for the right to marry. Some of those couples had already been together for a long time and were converting civil partnerships. Others rushed to the altar in the first wave of legalisation. Neither group is representative of same-sex marriage as a whole.
The median duration of same-sex female marriages ending in divorce in 2022 was 6.3 years. That’s not because lesbian marriages are inherently short-lived – it’s because same-sex marriage itself hasn’t existed long enough for there to be any 15 or 20-year divorces yet. Give it time.
The percentages sound scarier than they are
When people say “72% of same-sex divorces are between women,” that sounds catastrophic. But the absolute numbers are small. In 2019, there were 589 same-sex divorces between women in England and Wales, out of a total of over 107,000 divorces. Same-sex divorces of all kinds accounted for less than 1% of all divorces. The percentages within same-sex divorce are skewed because more women get married in the first place – 56% of same-sex marriages in 2019 were between women.
You may also like: What sapphic couples should know about getting divorced
Lesbian marriages are compared to the wrong benchmark
Most commentary compares lesbian divorce rates to heterosexual divorce rates and concludes that lesbian relationships are less stable. But this ignores a crucial piece of context: women initiate 69% of all heterosexual divorces. Not 50%. Not even 55%. Nearly seven in ten.
When a marriage has two women in it, both partners belong to the demographic group that is already more likely to end an unhappy marriage. This isn’t a lesbian problem. It’s a woman-having-higher-standards problem. We’ll come back to this.
So what’s really going on?
The honest answer is: several things at once, and most of them are more about gender than sexuality.
Women leave unhappy relationships. That’s not a flaw.
The Stanford sociologist Michael Rosenfeld’s research found that women initiate 69% of divorces in heterosexual marriages, but that in non-marital relationships, breakups are initiated equally by men and women. His conclusion was that women experience the institution of marriage as more constraining than men do, not that women are worse at relationships.
In a lesbian marriage, both partners are women. Both are statistically more likely to act when a relationship isn’t working. That’s not a sign of dysfunction – it’s arguably a sign that neither partner is staying in a bad situation out of financial dependence, social pressure, or inertia.
As one family law professional put it, the factors that lead lesbians to divorce are the same ones that lead women in heterosexual marriages to petition at twice the rate of men.
Minority stress is real
Minority stress theory describes how living in a heteronormative, sometimes hostile society creates chronic stress that straight couples simply don’t face. Lesbian couples deal with discrimination, family rejection, legal and financial inequalities, and the everyday exhaustion of existing in a world that wasn’t built for them. All of that puts pressure on a relationship in ways that are hard to quantify but very real to live with.
There’s no script – and that’s both good and bad
Heterosexual relationships come with a well-worn cultural script: dating, engagement, marriage, house, and kids. You don’t have to follow it, but it exists. Lesbian relationships don’t have that framework in the same way. That freedom is one of the best things about queer relationships – you get to build something that’s actually yours. But it also means there’s less external scaffolding holding things together when times get hard. No one’s mother is telling you to “work through it.” Society isn’t invested in your marriage the same way.
The U-Haul factor
We move fast. We know this about ourselves. The joke exists for a reason. And while there’s nothing inherently wrong with moving quickly, some couples who merge their lives rapidly may find that the intensity of early connection doesn’t always translate into long-term compatibility. That’s not unique to lesbians, but the cultural tendency toward fast commitment might mean some relationships formalise before they’ve had the chance to settle.
You may also like: Where is gay marriage allowed?
The bit nobody talks about
Here’s what gets lost when people fixate on divorce rates: research consistently shows that lesbian couples report equal or higher levels of relationship satisfaction compared to heterosexual couples. Multiple studies have found no significant differences in relationship satisfaction, commitment, passion, or intimacy based on sexual orientation.
A 12-year longitudinal study by Gottman – one of the most respected relationship researchers in the world – found that satisfaction and stability in gay and lesbian relationships are related to the same emotional qualities as in heterosexual relationships. The ingredients for a lasting relationship are the same regardless of who’s in it: good communication, shared values, mutual respect, and willingness to repair after conflict.
Lesbian couples who stay together tend to report higher levels of relationship quality than their gay male or heterosexual counterparts. Several studies have noted that lesbian couples specifically tend to score higher on measures of relationship quality and satisfaction.
So the full picture isn’t “lesbian relationships don’t last.” It’s more like: “lesbian couples who are happy tend to be very happy, and lesbian couples who aren’t happy are less likely to stick around pretending.”
That sounds pretty healthy to us.
Final thoughts
Do lesbian relationships last? Some do, and some don’t – just like every other kind of relationship. The divorce stats are real, but they’re a snapshot of a very young dataset, inflated by small sample sizes, warped by the fact that women generally have higher standards for staying in marriages, and completely silent on the question of relationship quality.
The next time someone throws the “lesbian divorce rate” at you as a gotcha, remember this: in heterosexual marriages, women initiate nearly 70% of divorces. When you have a marriage with two women in it, it makes complete sense that the divorce rate would be higher. The interesting question isn’t “why do lesbians divorce more?” It’s “why do women leave bad marriages?” And the answer to that one is: because they can. Because they should. Because staying in a relationship that isn’t working isn’t a measure of success.
A lasting relationship is a wonderful thing. But ending one that isn’t right for you? That’s definitely not failure. That’s self-respect.
Nonchalant x
You may also like
This article was written by one of our creative team writers here at Nonchalant Magazine.
